If you’re exploring house-sitting opportunities or searching for a reliable sitter to care for your home and pets, two of the most talked-about platforms are TrustedHousesitters and House Sitters America.
Both have loyal followings and offer unique benefits, but which one is right for you? This blog post breaks down key comparison points based on user priorities, platform capabilities, and real-world user experiences.
💰 1. Membership Fees and Value
As of July 2025, TrustedHousesitters charges $129 per year for sitter-only access and $179 for combined sitter/homeowner memberships. House Sitters America charges $49 annually for access to their platform.
- Dealbreaker? If cost is your primary concern, House Sitters America is more affordable. However, TrustedHousesitters justifies its higher price with added benefits like sit protection and 24/7 vet advice.
🌍 2. Geographic Coverage
- TrustedHousesitters: Global (Europe, North America, Australia, etc.)
- House Sitters America: U.S.-only
Verdict: For international sits, go with TrustedHousesitters. U.S.-only users may prefer House Sitters America for local focus.
🛡️ 3. Verification and Safety
- TrustedHousesitters: Offers ID checks and mandatory reviews
- House Sitters America: Basic verification only
Winner: TrustedHousesitters for its robust trust-building features.
📱 4. Platform Usability
- TrustedHousesitters: Sleek interface, great mobile app
- House Sitters America: Simpler, more basic design
Mobile-first? You’ll appreciate TrustedHousesitters.
☎️ 5. Customer Support
- TrustedHousesitters: 24/7 support + help center
- House Sitters America: Email-based, slower replies
Support Edge: TrustedHousesitters for immediate help.
🌐 6. Community and Reviews
- TrustedHousesitters: Larger, more reviews
- House Sitters America: Smaller but trusted user base
Trusted metric: Tie: They both have a trusted user base
🏰 7. Platform Features
- TrustedHousesitters: Vet access, cancellation insurance, mobile app
- House Sitters America: Core sit-matching features
Feature-Packed? TrustedHousesitters offers more perks.
⚡ 8. Success Rates
- TrustedHousesitters: More listings, faster matches
- House Sitters America: Less competition with fewer members
Momentum: House Sitter America has the advantage.
📜 9. Insurance and Protections
- TrustedHousesitters: Includes sit protection
- House Sitters America: No formal insurance
Risk-Averse? TrustedHousesitters has you covered.
📲 10. Mobile Experience
- TrustedHousesitters: Has a mobile app
- House Sitters America: Mobile web only
App Enthusiasts: Stick with TrustedHousesitters.
✍️ Personal Experience
I’ve personally used TrustedHousesitters for over eight years, both as a homeowner and as a sitter. During that time, I’ve completed dozens of successful sits across different continents and welcomed trusted individuals into my own home as well.
The platform has consistently delivered reliability, professional support, and meaningful connections that have led to repeat sits and lasting friendships. My experience gives me a unique lens through which to compare these services.
✅ Final Verdict
Choose TrustedHousesitters if:
- You want international opportunities 🌎
- You prioritize insurance and safety 🛡️
- You prefer a modern, app-based experience 📱
Choose House Sitters America if:
- You want a U.S.-only focus 🇺🇸
- You need a low-cost entry point 💸
- You’re comfortable with basic support and features ✉️
Each platform has its strengths, so the best choice depends on your specific needs. Whether you’re looking to explore new places while house sitting or find a trusted person to care for your pets, both platforms can serve you well with the right expectations.
Author: Britt
I am Britt. I have been house-sitting and pet-sitting for the past seven years. I have cared for 25 dogs, 35 cats, one turtle, and one rabbit over 80+ houses in 15 countries.
The opportunity to experience different homes, cultures, and communities has been extraordinary.
I’ve connected with homeowners seeking reliable sitters through house-sitting platforms like Aussie House Sitters and Trusted House Sitters. This unique way of living has allowed me to save money on accommodation, explore new cultures, and meet new people.
Being a member of these platforms has broadened my horizons and opened doors to short- and long-term house-sitting jobs. I’ve found joy in providing excellent pet care and ensuring the home is well-maintained.
I get many questions about how to start as a housesitter, so please reach out if you have any questions! I want everyone to enjoy this incredible lifestyle as well!
You can read more about Jay and me here!
Or connect with me on Facebook or in our house-sitting community on Facebook.
